Finding out which company offers the best insurance rates for drivers with a bad driving record in Indiana will involve a bit more work than just picking a company at random. Every insurance company has a proprietary method to determine rates, so we will examine the overall cheapest insurance companies in Indiana.

We do need to point out that Indiana insurance rates are calculated based on many things that will increase or decrease the cost of your policy. Simply having another birthday, buying another vehicle, or getting into an accident can trigger rate changes that can make some companies cheaper than competitors.

Find Cheaper Car Insurance for Imperfect Drivers

Compare Rates Today

Travelers offers some of the most affordable car insurance rates in Indiana at around $620 per year. USAA, Cincinnati Insurance, Erie, and Indiana Farmers Mutual also qualify as some of the cheaper Indiana insurance companies.

As shown above, if you are a policyholder with Erie and switched to Travelers, you might achieve a yearly price reduction of approximately $92. Drivers with Indiana Farmers Mutual may save as much as $221 a year, and The Hartford policyholders might realize rate reductions of up to $243 a year.

These prices are averages for all ages of drivers and types of vehicles and do not factor in a price surcharge for drivers with a bad driving record. So the insurer that has the lowest price for you may not even be in the list above. That underscores the importance of why you need to compare as many prices as possible using your own personalized driver profile and vehicle information.

The car, truck, or SUV you are seeking coverage for is one of the main factors when shopping for cheap coverage for drivers with a bad driving record. Vehicles with economical engines, good crash test ratings, or a low likelihood of liability claims will cost significantly less to insure than higher performance models. The table below features insurance costs for some of the most budget-friendly vehicles to buy coverage for.

Cheapest Vehicles to Insure for Drivers with a Bad Driving Record in Indiana
Vehicle Estimated Cost for Full Coverage
Ford Escape XLT 2WD $2,041
Honda Accord LX-P 4-Dr Sedan $2,061
Honda CR-V EX-L 2WD $2,065
Toyota Prius $2,132
Hyundai Elantra SE Touring Station Wagon $2,194
Volkswagen Jetta 2.0T Station Wagon $2,313
GMC Sierra SLE Regular Cab 2WD $2,342
Toyota Tacoma Double Cab TRD Sport Package 4WD $2,365
Honda Civic DX 4-Dr Sedan $2,391
Ford Focus S 4-Dr Sedan $2,399
Toyota RAV4 4WD $2,414
Chevrolet Equinox LT 2WD $2,439
Ford Fusion S 4-Dr Sedan $2,447
Dodge Grand Caravan SXT $2,439
Ford Explorer Limited 4WD $2,466
Chevrolet Malibu LTZ $2,473
Chevrolet Impala LTZ $2,527
Compare Cheap Rates Go

Table data represents single male driver age 30, two speeding tickets, two at-fault accidents, $1,000 deductibles, and Indiana minimum liability limits. Discounts applied include multi-vehicle, homeowner, and multi-policy. Premium costs do not factor in vehicle garaging location which can influence premiums noticeably.

Looking at the rates, we can assume that vehicles like the Ford Escape, Honda Accord, Honda CR-V, Toyota Prius, and Hyundai Elantra are going to be a few of the most affordable vehicles to insure for bad drivers. The cost of auto insurance will be more expensive just because there is more liability exposure for drivers with a bad driving record, but in general those particular vehicles will most likely have the lowest prices available.

Accidents and violations increase rates

The recommended way to earn low insurance prices in Indiana for bad drivers is to be a safe driver and avoid at-fault accidents and violations. The example below illustrates how violations and accidents can increase insurance prices for each age group. Data assumes a married male driver, comprehensive and collision coverage, $250 deductibles, and no additional discounts are factored in.

The data in the chart shows the average cost of an auto insurance policy per year with a clean driving record and no accidents is $1,715. Add in one speeding ticket and the average cost rises to $1,968, an increase of $253 each year. Then add one accident along with the one speeding ticket and the 12-month cost of insurance for drivers with a bad driving record in Indiana increases to an average of $2,684. That's an increase of $969, or $81 per month, just for being a little careless behind the wheel!

Get discounts on Indiana auto insurance

Insurers that sell policies for drivers with a bad driving record may additionally offer special discounts that could reduce prices by as much as 25% or more if you meet specific eligibility requirements. Companies and a summarized list of policyholder discounts can be found below.

The illustration below illustrates the difference between insurance rates with and without discounts. The rate quotes are based on a female driver, two violations and two accidents, Indiana state minimum liability limits, comprehensive and collision coverage, and $250 deductibles. The first bar for each age group shows insurance cost with no discounts. The second shows the rates with paid-in-full, passive restraint, multiple policy, paperless filing, marriage, and homeowner discounts applied. When drivers take advantage of discounts, the average amount saved each year on insurance for drivers with a bad driving record is 29% or $1,404.

Here's why price comparisons are so important

Indiana insurance rates are impacted by many things which can substantially change your annual premium. Turning one year older, having a teenage driver, or having an accident may cause policy rate changes that may make certain companies more affordable than before.

Not only may your situation change, but car insurance companies file new Indiana auto insurance rates without warning in order to remain profitable. Heavier than normal losses can result in higher prices, while profitable underwriting may cause lower-priced Indiana car insurance rates.

For example, the data below analyzes the cheapest car insurance in Indiana for a 30-year-old male driver with a clear driving record, no claims, and a good credit rating. When quoting prices based on his personal profile, Travelers might offer the best car insurance rates in Indiana at $620 each year. This is $620 less than the average rate paid by Indiana drivers of $1,240. Cincinnati Insurance, USAA, Erie, and Indiana Farmers Mutual are also on the list of the most affordable Indiana auto insurance companies.

The chart below compares rates after we give the driver from the first example a claim or two, a lower credit rating, and a traffic citation. Since each company has their own unique process for determining rates, analyzing rate quotes could result in a new list of affordable companies as shown below.

Auto-Owners now has the best auto insurance rate in Indiana with The Hartford, Motorists Mutual, Cincinnati Insurance, and Nationwide also having competitive pricing. This shows why it is critical to perform a complete rate comparison when trying to get the most economical insurance rates for drivers with a bad driving record.

Prices are impacted by many things and can decrease or increase without notice, so the most affordable company three years ago may now be one of the more expensive options.

Tips for buying the cheapest insurance for drivers with a bad driving record

The list below details many thrifty ideas that can help you get cheap car insurance.

The last idea is especially important, as we pointed out in this piece. Auto insurance prices change frequently, so don't be hesitant to change insurance companies if a more affordable rate is found.

Brand loyalty is great, but it's not a great idea if that stubbornness costs you potentially thousands of dollars a year. Take a couple minutes and compare rates and find cheaper car insurance for drivers with a bad driving record.